Menu
Menu
Connect with UKCFA Facebook Twitter YouTube LinkedIn

We Want a Boy: The Ethics of Sex Selection in the Clinic

Controversy is no rarity in the field of reproductive endocrinology and infertility. Since its discovery and early clinical applications, everyone seemed to have (and still has) an opinion about in vitro fertilization (IVF) procedures. Many concerns are religious or political. Others are ethical, medical and genetic. With huge improvements in IVF laboratory techniques that now include preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) when appropriate, IVF patients may ask physicians to select only embryos of one sex or the other. They want to select their child’s sex.

The American Medical Association Journal of Ethics discusses this issue in its October 2014 Virtual Mentor section. Its content is captivating, addressing the question, “Do physicians or professional societies have the right to limit the use of these available techniques?” In some European countries, they do not. The United States has not regulated PGS to prohibit sex screening.

We Want a Boy The Ethics of Sex Selection in the Clinic
This article covers three techniques that currently can select for sex: prefertilization sperm sorting, PGS, and elective pregnancy termination after prenatal testing. Prefertilization sperm sorting, which is 84% to 92% accurate, is not available in the US. Terminating a pregnancy simply because the child’s sex is “wrong” is unethical.

Risk associated with pre-implantation PGS includes a chance that manipulation of embryos may affect their implantation potential. As this field is new, additional studies are needed to identify other risks. Patients need to know that the additional testing adds costs to an already costly procedure.

The authors discuss various possible situations when patients may ask to select the child’s sex. They may want to balance a family that already has one or more children of one gender. Or, they may simply prefer to have a boy or girl. Making these decisions could cause contribute imbalance of the sexes in the general population.

American Society for Reproductive Medicine Ethics Committee does not encourage use of PGS solely for the purpose of determining sex. At Albert Einstein College of Medicine’s Montefiore Medical Center, all requests to select sex using PGS are referred to the ethics committee. The Society for Assisted Reproductive Technologies is collecting data prospectively for all PGD cases conducted at their affiliated programs. Their plan is to assess the prevalence of PGS for sex selection and develop indications.

Source: www.hcplive.com

 

Perihan and Chris Cartledge went on fertility courses in Germany, the USA and Turkey in their six-year quest to have baby they longed for. A couple desperate for a child travelled 15,000 miles for IVF...
Infertile women forced to use donor eggs still pass their DNA to their child The 'amazing discovery' was made by scientists at a Spanish fertility clinic Had been thought fertilised egg only had DNA...
Controversy is no rarity in the field of reproductive endocrinology and infertility. Since its discovery and early clinical applications, everyone seemed to have (and still has) an opinion about in vitro...
One of the most important medical conferences in North America focusing on the field of Infertility Medicine is being hosted by Charleston’s own Coastal Fertility Specialists, March 5 – 8, 2015 at Belmond...
Atlanta Center for Reproductive Medicine invites women to attend a discussion and social gathering on March 30 to learn more about egg freezing. Build your family when the time is right for you. Atlanta,...

Arrange an appointment with us

We have fertility clinics located all over the UK and beyond, so your nearest clinic shouldn't be too far away.



Contact our UK Coordinator to arrange an appointment with one of our fertility specialists.

Telephone +44 (0)800 689 1317 Telephone +44 (0)7860 439346 Email appointments@ukcfa.co.uk
Enter the details of your enquiry and we will be in touch as soon as possible.

captcha
Reload